The Cenotaph 1.0

Very nice BAT, but the lot is terrible. It needs a lot more detail, and perhaps a few sims standing around. A few trees, as well. I'll download this, and give it a try, but if i were you, i'd try to put at least a few details on the lot and give it less of a "vanilla" look.

I give it 4/5. it is quite good for a first attempt. Keep it up!

Sorry for double posting, but why is this a RAR file? That type of file is VERY inconvenient.

could look even beter if you added a few trees on the grass.... just a proposition if you want to work on it more

A very good representation of a war memorial (which often do have a blank space around it, trees and stuff wouldn't go) however it is a .rar....

BAT is good, but the lotting is...I'd say, underrated.

I do live in HK and I will say that it's really empty like that. It's just a lawn and the place is closed off most of the time to the public. Though, I do think the lot was about three times as large.

Good work

The cenotaph looks great but the lot is empty. However because I can fix it with the Lot Editor, I'll give you 5/5
Keep it up, but next time don't forget to make a nice lot as well

What's the problem with RAR files, anyway? Get a good free and open-source application like 7-Zip, and it's very likely that you'll never have to worry about archive formats again because that software pretty much covers all regular formats like ZIP, RAR, TAR.GZ etc. etc.

profxyz, I think that's a really decent first upload, and you have my respect for taking that step from "leecher" to uploader. You made a good choice, too, by starting with a smaller object. Are you planning to open a BAT thread? I'm asking because IMO that would be a better place to give feedback and discuss things. In any case, keep it up!

Before hoping that you will open a BAT thread, i hope you will keep up...this upload was a really pleasant surprise.[b]

[/b]

Unfortunately, I am not so acquainted with Simtropolis as to know what a BAT thread is ...

Go [url="https://www.simtropolis.com/forum/forum/12-bat-open-discussion/"]there[/url], then search for the "start a new topic" button, and then press it...your BAT thread is done.

Pretty good. I will use Lot Editor to add some random people to it I think. Some cenotaphs, for example the one in Ottawa, are in highly used public spaces so there is some foot traffic.

Could maybe use a little more work & the lot could use some props though, but it is nicely done for your first.I think you should keep praticing as you have
potential.

Wow I am surprised somebody would do the HK Cenotaph. It seems almost 1/2 of Central District of HK is done by now. About the lot size, I think 3x3 is fine, because the AIG Tower located very near it almost has the same lot size, and Cockatoo's AIG Tower is available on the STEX as a 3x3 lot. Perhaps this would receive a better rating if it is done as a 2x2, but the current 3x3 bare lot actually quite authentic, for those who don't know. Therefore, I am giving this a 5/5 to raise its mediocre sub 4.0 rating.

good idea