Illogical arguments against civil rights fairness

[SRS 9]

Someone here said this: "Personally I do not support gay marriage, but I do support gay rights (does that sound like a dichotomy?)."

What it is illogical. Gay people marry one another because they're gay. Stating that they shouldn't be able to marry each other is the antithesis of supporting their rights.

The only logical basis for arguing against same-sex marriage is when one claims that gay people don't exist. Because they do exist, that argument has no value.

This topic is for rebutting any argument against any group's rights, whether it involves gay rights or something else. It's also for asking questions, if you're unsure about the logical soundness of a particular claim/argument.