First post to the site, so here's as good a place as any to get started.
My vote was based on whether I would purchase the game with the information I have now. That being said, I gave it a 1; I would not spend money on this game. If EA made the decision to pull the Origin requirement, I would push it up to a 2. I would wait-and-see about buying, but I would not make a decision until after I returned from deployment as I'm not spending money on a game that I couldn't play for 9 months. Remove the always online requirement and it jumps to 4 and I'd set out to find somewhere to pre-order.