Rate that CJ Picture Game!

[Haljackey 17,398]

Hello everyone, this is my first forum game: Rate that CJ Picture Game!

Ratings go anywhere from 1-10.  Decimal points are allowed. 

Anyways, the rules are simple:

1.  Post a picture from a CJ.

2.  Be sure to give ample credit to the maker of that picture

3.  Cite which CJ its from (you can provide a page # and link too, but its not needed)

4.  You CAN post pictures from your own CJ if you have one, as long as it isn't for self-promotion.

5.  You can comment on just about everything about the picture.  Criticism is allowed, as long as its constructive.

6.  You don't have to post another picture after you rate, this game isn't consecutive like other game.  Just keep rating that one picture until another's posted.  Even if another is posted, you can still comment on pictures before it.

Anyways, let me start to make sure we get off the right foot:

This picture was taken from Marshall, MN, USA: The Train 'n' Grain Capitol of the US!  This picture was made by tomdapom.

This CJ is made by tomdapom.

You can find the picture on PAGE 3.

---

...And there you have it!  Now all you have to do is rate it /10.  You can post another image if you like.

I hope you like this game.  Have fun!

Best,

-Haljackey

[Raritan Express 0]

Rating: 7.5

Comments: I think the building's roof could have a little more detail and have the HVAC ports look more realistic. The building design is good and the angle and setting is nice. I like the parking lot too but having a car parked right next too the sidewalk in front of the tree seems somewhat strange.

[Smarty218 2]

I'll give it a 7, nothing really interesting...

Heres one from my own CJ: "Smarty's Showcase!".

[bakercity 270]

I will give it a solid 7.

[tomdapom 79]

I'll give it a 5/10. The picture is at a weird angle, the mall seems a bit . . . dead. However, your use of Porkies trees and French BATs boosts the image up a bit. I suggest in the future:

- Leaving your pictures as they are when they're taken. Sim City isn't a 3-D game.

- Adding some more life to your mall, by making people show up, lining it with trees, or whatever!

[Smarty218 2]

Ok

1. I haven't changed or photoshopped this at all

2. It is zoomed way out, or else there would be people

But thanks for the constructive criticism!