The largest topic on ST?

[jugioh1012 2]

What do you think is the largest topic/thread on the Simtropolis forums?(amount of pages)

Just out of pure curiosity

[Joesocwork 4]

As an Administrator that was suprisingly easy to find out.  But I'll let others guess for fun first.

[Firebird 40]

My guess is that its them Schulmania folks over there.

[Jasoncw 11,841]

You can sort threads in each forum by the number of posts by clicking on "Posts".  It looks like The Avatar Above Me game is the winner.

So what's the biggest thread that has something to do with SimCity? 

[Glenni 1,444]

The BAT request thread , but it's probably just full of junk anyway....

[Joesocwork 4]

^ Too many newbies making silly requests, huh!

[jugioh1012 2]

Joesocwork,whatcha talkin' about?Are you calling me a Newbie?LOL!!!I played this game since 2004,been on the site since 06

Oooo,or are you talking about the BAT Request Thread?

[Meg 368]

Schulmania is in the top 10.

The BAT request thread is not.

The BAT request thread is currently number 20.

[sebbyb07 2]

the Post Your Pic thread should be pretty high!

[Joesocwork 4]

Originally posted by: jugioh1012 Joesocwork,whatcha talkin' about?Are you calling me a Newbie?LOL!!!I played this game since 2004,been on the site since 06

Oooo,or are you talking about the BAT Request Thread?

quote>

 

No, I'm tweaking anyone who may not have respect for our earnest newcomers or novices to SimTropolis or to BAT'ing/ CJ'ing etc., whoever they may be.

[Silur 3,304]

Originally posted by: Firebird My guess is that its them Schulmania folks over there. quote>

 

I think so too ...., but there is no any my comments on this thread ...

[jugioh1012 2]

Ahhhh,OK!I agree with Jasoncw,"The avatar above me" seems really big

[Silur 3,304]

Yes it is, may be largest thread on Simtropolis is "The avatar above me" - but this thread was from 2004 ... - and "Schulmania" thread was from 2006 ....

May be we must look at Reply/Day data ?

[Meg 368]

Should we see who can come the closest to guessing the top 10?

[beebs 129]

Ok I was bored. Here's what I came up with.

1. Avatar Above Me

2. Jacky's Kabin (version 1)

3. A-Z Cities

4. Schulmania

5. Sig Above Me

6. Word Association Game

7. Post Your Picture Thread

8. Moose Factory (version 1)

9. Anduin Valley Revisited

10. Jacky's Kabin (version 2)

[Joesocwork 4]

No helping, Jason and other Moderators.   There's an actual page that gives the top stats the Administrators can look at.   (Oooops, did I give away a secret Ski? )

[Micah 16]

Ah, please!!!! Please, Joe!

Just one guess: Jacky's Kabin (first version)

That thread was by far the largest back then so I don't see why it wouldn't be now. I know for sure that it's not Schulmania because he hasn't even gotten to the 200 page mark.

[Cleaner475 150]

Nice list beebs, I wanna know what it is but I bet its in the Forum Games section,

Richard

[Duke87 1,070]

These are all the publicly viewable threads with over 1000 replies:

Rank	Name	Replies	Date Started	Starter	Forum
1	The Avatar Above Me	7862	6/26/2004	clindhartsen	Forum Games
2	A - Z Cities Game	6602	4/3/2004	simwario	Forum Games
3	Schulmania: SC4 - Real Life Crossover	5919	10/5/2006	Schulmanator	City Journals
4	The Signature Above Me	5641	6/26/2004	clindhartsen	Forum Games
5	Word Association Game II	5247	6/27/2004	simwario	Forum Games
6

[Interchange 0]

The game threads are usually always the largest. The ones on my forum are too. It's just the fact that they're fun, and easy to post on that makes them go for so long. No real topic to them that could just be finished in x amount of posts. Nice list you've compiled there, Duke!

[Duke87 1,070]

Doesn't all fit in one post

58	Tonksies BAT Thread NDEX	1257	2/17/2005	ILL Tonkso	BAT - NDEX Board Room
59	The Headwaters of Nemonos	1232	10/27/2006	Giligone	City Journals
60	The Brastoval Bay Area	1231	7/14/2005	aleking	City Journals
61	How Well Do You Know Europe?	1202	5/6/2007	Mike the Mayor	Forum Games
62	Hows the weather where you live?	1193	10/6/2004	dominohobbes	General Off-Topic
63	Cant't Find It? Ask Here!	1180	2/15/2007	Voar Tok	STEX - Simtropolis Exchange
64

[Meg 368]

Just checking something . . .

can you access this link?

[Interchange 0]

That linked me to the Palm Point CJ.

[Interchange 0]

That seems to be the only image left on that CJ. How old is that?

[Duke87 1,070]

Oooh, okay, I see. Older topics are still around, but only come up through searches, not through forum browsing, and thus big old ones don't come to the top when you sort descending by replies. Expletive, that makes this so much harder.

[Interchange 0]

Where do the old topics go when they "fall off the page"?

[Craig-Abcvs 1,595]

Originally posted by: Interchange Where do the old topics go when they "fall off the page"?quote>

 

I have heard a rumour that there is a shoe box taped on to the side of the ST server with 100 MPH tape...

...but of course I may be incorrect on this.

[Cleaner475 150]

Nic elist Duke - Its was pretty obvious the biggest topics would be forum games or CJs I don't think theres anywhere else with tons of updates all the time except for the occasional BAT thread,

Richard

[beebs 129]

Originally posted by: Duke87

Of course, that list is not technically complete. As you can see from beebs' post, the old versions of Jackie's Kabin and the Moose Factory are up there, but they've been archived, and thus to anyone but a staff member might as well no longer exist.quote>

Just do a search for Jacky's Kabin or the Moose Factory. They still show up in the search engine, just not in the forum listings. I found it myself via the search engine.

Edit: Oops. You already determined that yourself. Well fine then. Serves me right for trying to be helpful when I really should be sleeping.

[Micah 16]

Wait, what version of Jacky's Kabin is that? Is number 8 version 1 or 2?