Jump to content
ammo8121

Education without schools

9 posts in this topic Last Reply

Recommended Posts

I recently started playing SimCity 4 again. I tried to create 2 residential zones with one having no education, and the other having full education. Basically trying to divide classes. About 10 years in, my no education zone got as educated as my fully educated area. Is this a bug? I was trying to keep the uneducated zone low wealth

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've consistently found it very difficult to create low, med, and high wealth divisions in SC4.  I've tried using garbage dumps and starving resources and cutting off traffic, taxing the poor to feed the rich, but it seems as soon as there's any med or high wealth or availability of civil services, the Sims are very nice people who lift up their neighbors to at least med wealth.   

SC4 doesn't start at a condition of complete scarcity of resources and lack of availability of skill and tech, it more so begins in the 20th century with an optimistic vision that if you manage things well, you can build utopia.   A lot of the game is focused on crisis management and enabling the player to succeed.      

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is this a bug?  Most likely not.  Why is this happening?  The best answer is "It depends!"  I obviously don't know specifics about the city you are developing so most of this the following is very generic.

It depends on whether you are playing plain vanilla, or are using custom content.  Some custom content can have stats that are very different to similar Maxis facilities, especially radius being served, and often, amount of EQ boost. 

Don't forget that there are other buildings that might provide a more hefty EQ boost than schools, over a much wider area, sometimes to a much large segment of the population.  Think museums and libraries.  Again the stats issue for custom content vs. plain vanilla.

Don't forget that unlike public safety facilities, an education facility exerts its full effect to every tile within its radius of effect.

It depends on the size of the city square you are trying to develop.  A Maxis school (effect radius - 512 m), even if placed in the extreme corner of a small city square (1,000 x 1,000 m) is going to exert its influence over almost a quarter of the city square.  Place that same facility in the middle of the same city square and its effect covers almost 80% of the city square.  A Maxis Museum (effect radius - 5800m) will exert its effect on every tile of a large city square, no matter where it's placed in that city square.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
55 minutes ago, twalsh102 said:

It depends on the size of the city square you are trying to develop.  A Maxis school (effect radius - 512 m), even if placed in the extreme corner of a small city square (1,000 x 1,000 m) is going to exert its influence over almost a quarter of the city square.  Place that same facility in the middle of the same city square and its effect covers almost 80% of the city square.  A Maxis Museum (effect radius - 5800m) will exert its effect on every tile of a large city square, no matter where it's placed in that city square.

For the elementary and high schools one can simply turn off the buses. (Adjust bus funding to zero.) Then the radius is considerably smaller. The museum and college do affect the whole tile as you said. This is likely where the Sims are getting their education.

For example I always play large tiles now and I'll get it mostly covered with farms and residential and a wee bit of commercial and industry before I do any education stuff. Now, I'll get my city stabilized so the population is not fluctuating by more than single digit denizens. I'll add one single elementary school with no buses, one library, and one museum. Then I provide health care to every one of the Sims. Let it run long enough and because the museum educates the older Sims and those Sims live a long time they can get fairly smart. When a Sim dies they are replaced by a younger one who inherits half of the parent's EQ. Even when born outside the radius of the school and library it's enough that they don't lose all their EQ by the time the museum kicks in for them. So when they die at a ripe old age they are smarter than their parent at that age and therefore their offspring is a bit smarter starting out than they were. With a totally stable population and enough health to get a life span a little above 80 years you can achieve a 120 overall EQ with one elementary school, one library, and one museum. With 100 year life spans you can get about 160 overall EQ from the same 3 buildings.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Original Poster
  • I have each zone on a different side of the map, so the radii of the schools in the educated section are not even close to the other one. In the graphs it shows much less eq in the uneducated section, but if you click on the houses, it says education is high. I only have a hospital and police station in the uneducated part as well. I even had some high wealth move on in lol. I have NAM installed btw

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites

    So, no museum or college in that city tile? Not even one? Then are you using any custom content plugins? Perhaps something there is boosting education? Otherwise, I'm going to have to guess the Sims are getting smart on one side of the map then moving to the other side and being replaced with fresh Sims wanting to attend the schools on the first side of the map.

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites

    Are the neighborhoods new?  Meaning, have they had a lot of sims move in in the last 10 years?  If they have then what you are seeing is that each new sim starts with a base EQ.  This is independent of any existing factors (such as schools/no schools).  As the sim ages this base EQ will slowly erode if there are no Education buildings within reach of the sim.  The next generation that moves into the house inherits 1/2 of the previous sims EQ number.  10 sim years is not nearly long enough to see this effect.  You will have to run the simulation much longer to see the EQ level of the schooled to rise and the unschooled lower.

    Also keep in mind that the EQ graph is the average for the city.  So even if you have some educated sims, or new sims moving in, it will never go to zero.

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites
  • Original Poster
  • I have a museum, high school, elementary school, and a library in the northeast residential section of the city tile. In the south west residential section there are no education buildings. I did not know sims moved to different parts of the city. Guess I'll have to just do an uneducated city square and educated city square. Will they move in between squares of the region? Guess I could make a low wealth and higher wealth city square in the region. Then just hike the taxes on what i don't want in each tile

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites
    4 hours ago, ammo8121 said:

    I have a museum, high school, elementary school, and a library ...

    The museum is the culprit in this case. Its effect is city wide and affects the older generations. When they die their replacements (in the same house) come in with half of the EQ of the older Sim who went to that big electronic grave yard in the sky. As I said in my post above this is one way to educate the whole city tile with a minimum of an elementary school, a library, and a museum. Just those 3 buildings for education along with good health care coverage and lots of time with a stable population will do it. For the effect you are after, take out the museum and you should be able to get medium wealth around the other education facilities and low wealth outside of their influence.

    Now yes, you can also separate the medium and low wealth by having them in their own separate city tiles. This is technically easier to manage.

    Additionally, you could make a mod to prevent the higher wealth levels from kicking out and taking over the lower wealth parcels. That's what I did in this post which allows me to have all wealth levels near each other regardless of the other later influences I add in. None of the homes in this pic were marked historical. They all show high School and Hospital Grades yet will stay put year in and year out.

    02 LMH Wealth.jpg

     

    Other modders are aware of how to make this, but apparently no one else has tested it to any significant degree for fear it will make super high density skyscraper cities more difficult. I'm using the mod I made in my own region and I absolutely love it. I am, however, creating a rural farming community with small towns so I cannot say how it would affect a metalostrophy design. It's simple to create. Or if you want to experiment with it, I can attach mine to a post. I'm using it along with @Bones1's Less Abandonment Mod.

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an Account  

    Sign up to join our friendly community. It's easy!  

    Register a New Account

    Sign In  

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now


    • Similar Content

      • By Moses Zal
        Hey guys,
        I always noticed this happening. When I lower the funding of the maxis jail because I have much less than 1,000 inmates inside the prison, I start to see prisoners running and cops trying to catch them on foot. Of course when I am lowering the funding, I am always keeping the capacity more that the number of inmates. Does this mean that prisoners are escaping or is it just an annoying eye candy? 
        Edit: I got the answer, It didn't came to my mind to look for the answer in Prima's official e-guide before posting. Decreasing funding of jails increases the chances of a prison break.
      • By Supernia
        SimCity 4 was released for PC on January 14, 2003.
         
        Happy birthday SC4! 
      • By Chief ZDN
        Hello,
        My idea on mod listing is failed because it has a fatal flaw: it's not hassle-less. So, I'll redefine the existing Modpacc. The new Modpacc uses a LEX Deptracker-like system, but it's completely decentralized (even at the specification except for approving team but it's elected by the community). It's more reliable than the mod listing system and less expensive than the package management system. And, it's legal both for creators and site owners since site owner can opt-in to be integrated (meaning opt-out site behaves like an external site on LEX) and no ads circumvention involved.
        The spec is coming soon but suggestions are welcome. There are 2 versions of spec offered, HTML and PDF. And, it's open source, meaning you can suggest changes on the spec easily and approved by the rolling approving team elected based on trust and contributions but still democratic.
        Thanks.
      • By jmak
        Hello,
        Over the last few weeks I have been developing a multiplayer region system for SimCity 4, which I have named Poppy Multiplayer Regions (PMR). Now that it has reached the Release Candidacy stage, I would like to share it all with you.
        You can register for an account and download the second release candidate of the PMR Launcher at http://getpmr.com/
        Of course, you probably do not trust programs from unknown developers. So, I have also provided the Python source code at https://github.com/cizmic/pmr-client for you to review and run.
        What makes PMR different from Dropbox regions?
        Primitive multiplayer regions have been explored in SimCity 4 for quite some time in the form of shared Dropbox directories. While they worked most of the time, these regions had three major flaws:
        No city permissions. There was no real way of protecting one's saves from others, since Dropbox regions were typically configured to handle permissions only at the directory level. As a result, most regions were strictly private. Adjacent save overwriting. In every save operation, SimCity 4 doesn't just modify the current tile, but also the adjacent tiles. Because of this, it was previously impossible for two players to play in adjacent cities at the same time. Complicated setup. This isn't such an issue for powerusers, but configuring SimCity 4 to run from the Dropbox path was tricky for many newer players. PMR overcomes all of these issues by having a server and launcher that are specifically designed for SimCity 4 regions. I have attached a diagram that shows how the saving system allows for city permissions and adjacent playing.
        How to try PMR out
        If you want to try out Poppy Multiplayer Regions, just follow these steps:
        Register for an account at http://getpmr.com/join Download the launcher from the PMR website, or download from the STEX Install and launch the client. Then, connect to a region and log in with your PMR account. The PMR Launcher does all of the synchronization and launching for you. You can view the Readme file that installs with the launcher for more information.
        How permissions work in PMR
        PMR uses what is known as a claims system. In this system, you can only edit cities that you have claimed. All other saves will be ignored by the server. To claim an unoccupied tile, just save it; you can find unoccupied tiles in the Launcher Map that pops up whenever you connect to a region.
        Choose wisely -- you can only claim one tile per region, and you can't abandon a claim.
        What's next?
        PMR is still a work in progress -- the launcher is still a Release Candidate. I've ironed out most of the kinks, but there still might be some small bugs and errors. I'd greatly appreciate it if you could try out the launcher and give me feedback to improve it.
        So far, there is only one region ("Anise") that consists of 36 large tiles. I'm not sure how quickly this will fill up, but when it does I will expand it or add another region.
        A note on plugins
        PMR synchronizes plugins, and I've included my Underwater Ferry Connectors in the Anise plugins set to demonstrate this. Since redistributing others' plugins requires explicit permission, I am wondering if anybody is interested in having their plugins added to the Anise region.
        Thanks, and have fun!

      • By jmak
        In order to use this launcher, you will need to register for a PMR account at http://getpmr.com/join
        Poppy Multiplayer Regions (PMR) is a new multiplayer solution for SimCity 4 that allows for save protection and adjacent tile editing. The PMR launcher automatically synchronizes regions and launches SimCity 4 for you -- all you have to do is choose a region and log in.
        To learn more about PMR, please see my post on the forums. There is also a Readme that is installed along with the launcher.
    • Recently Browsing   0 members

      No registered users viewing this page.

    ×

    Season's Greetings!

    xmas popup.jpg

    Thank You for the Continued Support!

    Simtropolis relies mainly on member donations to continue operating. Without your support, we just would not be able to be entering our 15th year online!  You've really help make this a great community.

    But we still need your support to stay online. If you're able to, please consider a donation to help us stay up and running, so that we can help keep bringing SimCity players together to share our creations.

    Make a Donation, Get a Gift!

    Expand your city with the best from the Simtropolis Echange.
    Make a donation and get one or all three discs today!

    stexcollection-header.png

    By way of a "Thank You" gift, we'd like to send you our STEX Collector's DVD. It's some of the best buildings, lots, maps and mods collected for you over the years. Check out the STEX Collections for more info.

    Each donation helps keep Simtropolis online, open and free!

    Thank you for reading and enjoy the site!

    More About STEX Collections